By Bonnie Durkin - 5/27/26

By Bonnie Durkin - 5/27/26

Author, Speaker, Energy Alignment Practitioner & Personal Empowerment Coach

Why You Keep Going Back to the Old Version of You

Have you ever noticed how easy it is to start changing… but how hard it can be to stay changed?

You get motivated.
You clean up your eating.
You start exercising.
You meditate.
You journal.
You begin setting boundaries.
You feel inspired and hopeful.
And for a little while, it works.

But then slowly — sometimes almost without noticing — you begin slipping back into old habits, old reactions, old patterns, and old ways of thinking.

Before long, you feel like the “old you” again.

If you’ve ever experienced this, please know this:

You are not weak.
You are not broken.
And you are not failing.

What’s happening is much deeper than motivation.
You haven’t fully updated your identity yet.

The Brain Loves What’s Familiar

One of the most important things to understand about the brain and nervous system is this:

Your subconscious mind is designed to keep you safe — not necessarily happy, fulfilled, healthy, or successful.
Safe.

And to your subconscious mind, familiar equals safe.

Even when the familiar is unhealthy.
Even when the familiar keeps you stuck.
Even when the familiar makes you miserable.

Your brain creates neural pathways through repetition. The more you think, feel, and behave a certain way, the more automatic those patterns become.

Eventually, they become your identity.

“This is just who I am.”
“I’ve always struggled with my weight.”
“I’m an anxious person.”
“I never follow through.”
“I’m not disciplined.”
“I’m always overwhelmed.”

Over time, the brain stops treating these thoughts like temporary experiences and starts treating them like facts.

And once your subconscious mind believes something is part of your identity, it will work very hard to keep you aligned with it.

That’s why change can feel so difficult.

You may consciously want something new while your subconscious mind is trying to pull you back toward what feels familiar and safe.

Why Motivation Alone Usually Doesn’t Last

This is why so many people can successfully “start” something but struggle to maintain it long term.

You can force yourself to go to the gym for a while. You can white-knuckle your way through a diet. You can push yourself to think positively for a few days.

But if your deeper identity still says:

“I’m overweight.”
“I’m unhealthy.”
“I’m lazy.”
“I’m stressed.”
“I always quit.”

…eventually your brain will try to return you to the version of yourself it recognizes.

Not because you lack willpower. Because your subconscious mind is trying to maintain consistency between your identity and your behavior.

Your Identity Creates Your “Normal”

Long-term change happens when the new behavior stops feeling forced and starts feeling natural.

When it becomes:
“This is who I am now.”
Instead of:
“I’m trying to work out.”
It becomes:
“I’m someone who takes care of my body.”
Instead of:
“I’m trying to be calmer.”
It becomes:
“I am becoming someone who feels grounded, safe, and emotionally regulated.”
Instead of:
“I’m trying to eat healthy.”
It becomes:
“I’m a healthy person, and this is how I naturally care for myself.”

This is identity-level change. And identity-level change changes everything.

The Power of Speaking Out Loud

One of the most powerful — and overlooked — ways to begin updating your identity is through your own voice.

Your voice carries emotional energy.

When you speak out loud, different parts of the brain activate compared to silent thinking alone.

Speaking engages motor regions, auditory processing centers, emotional centers, and reinforcement pathways in the brain.

In simple terms: Your brain pays more attention to what you say out loud.

Especially when those words are repeated consistently with emotion and intention.

Your nervous system is constantly listening to you.  The words you repeatedly speak become instructions.

This is why constantly saying things like:

“I’m exhausted.”
“I’m overwhelmed.”
“I’m a mess.”
“I’ll never change.”

…has such a powerful impact over time.

Your subconscious mind absorbs repetition. But the beautiful part is: It also absorbs new repetition.

You can begin intentionally teaching your brain and nervous system a new version of you.

Why Writing + Speaking + Listening Works So Well

One of the fastest ways to begin updating identity is to combine multiple forms of reinforcement together.

Write it.
Speak it.
Hear it.
Feel it.

When you write something longhand, it slows the brain down and creates stronger neurological encoding.

When you speak it out loud, you activate auditory and emotional reinforcement.

When you record your voice and listen repeatedly, you expose your subconscious mind to the new identity over and over again.

And when you combine this with tapping, breathwork, or mirror work, you help calm the nervous system while introducing the new belief.

That matters because the brain learns best when the body feels safe.

A nervous system stuck in stress tends to resist change.

A regulated nervous system becomes more open to new patterns.

Try This Practice

Take out a notebook and write: Who do I want to become?

Not just what do you want to have. Not just what do you want to change.

Who do you want to BE?

Then begin writing statements in the present tense as if you are already becoming that version of yourself.

For example:
“I am someone who takes care of my body.”
“I am calm, grounded, and emotionally strong.”
“I naturally make choices that support my well-being.”
“I trust myself.”
“I follow through.”
“I deserve to feel healthy and happy.”
“I am becoming the kind of person who creates the life I want.”

Then read them out loud slowly. Feel them. Even if they don’t feel fully true yet.

Especially then. Because you are introducing your brain to a new possibility.

If you really want to speed up the process, read them out loud while you tap.

Tapping helps calm and regulate the nervous system while also helping neutralize the inner resistance and “yeah buts…” that often come up when you try to introduce a new belief or identity.

It also helps the brain become more receptive to change and supports the creation of new neural pathways through repetition, emotional regulation, and focused attention.

The more relaxed and safe your nervous system feels, the easier it becomes for your subconscious mind to accept: “This is who I am now.”

Next, record yourself speaking them in a calm, encouraging voice.

Listen while walking.
Listen before bed.
Listen while tapping.
Listen while looking at yourself in the mirror.

Not to “fake” being someone else. But to gently teach your nervous system:
“This is safe now too.”

You Must Become the New You

If you want your life to change, you cannot continually rehearse the old version of yourself.

At some point, you must begin emotionally and mentally stepping into the new identity.

Not perfectly. Not all at once. But consistently.

The truth is: Your future is shaped not only by what you do occasionally… but by who you believe yourself to be.

The more you reinforce the identity of the person you are becoming, the more your choices, habits, emotions, and actions begin aligning naturally with that version of you.

And over time, what once felt difficult starts becoming familiar.

And eventually… It becomes you.

With love,
Bonnie

Enjoyed this article?

Each week I send out a free email filled with practical tools, mindset shifts, nervous system support, tapping techniques, and simple ways to feel better emotionally—without adding more to your already busy life.

If you’d like encouragement, inspiration, and easy-to-use strategies delivered right to your inbox, I’d love to stay connected.

👉 Sign up for my free weekly email below.

Small shifts really do create powerful change.

Weekly tips, tools, & processes to help you feel better and live the life of your dreams!

Fire Horse Energy

Embracing the Fire Horse Energy of 2026: Working with Fire Horse Energy & the Power of a Numerology One Year While many celebrate new beginnings on January 1st,

Read More »

Inputs Matter

What Are You Feeding Your Mind? “Stand guard at the doorway of your mind, letting in only what you wish to manifest.” – Ralph Waldo Emerson Have you

Read More »

Quick Stress Reset

Your Thoughts, Your Stress, Your Shift: Calming the Nervous System from the Inside Out “The greatest weapon against stress is our ability to choose one thought over another.”

Read More »

Closing the Gap

Closing the Gap: Becoming a Vibrational Match to What You Want Have you ever noticed the gap—the space between where you are right now and where you really want

Read More »

Savoring Summer

Savoring the Light: A Summer Solstice Invitation to Slow Down and Soak It All In Happy Summer Solstice and welcome to the official first day of summer in

Read More »

Mood Magnet

Your Mood is Your Magnet: How Feeling Good Attracts More Good! Have you ever noticed how some days everything just clicks? People smile at you, traffic lights turn

Read More »

Stressed to Calm

Breathe + Look + Tap = Shift! – From Stressed to Calm in Minutes! We all have days when stress creeps in, tension builds, and everything feels just

Read More »

Why You Procrastinate

The Hidden Reason Behind Procrastination (and How to Move Through It) Have you ever stared at a task for hours—or even days—knowing you need to do it, but

Read More »
To receive the Empowered To Thrive weekly newsletter delivered to your email, sign up below.